 (1).png){kind=spacer}
2 months ago
3
Subscribers can listen to this article
A mother holds her baby and the Road To Health Booklet, which is a record of a child's growth, immunisations, and health interventions. (Halden Krog/Spotlight)
- According to new data, global childhood immunisation coverage stalled in 2023, but it decreased in SA.
- A marker used to measure the coverage looks at whether children received three doses of the vaccine against diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis.
- The report ranks SA 6th-worst in the African region, with a total of 220 000 zero-dose children – children missing out on any vaccination.
A new report found that vaccination coverage rates around the world had not yet returned to levels seen in 2019, before the Covid-19 pandemic disrupted immunisation programmes.
There was no meaningful change in immunisation coverage between 2022 and 2023, according to a WHO and Unicef report published in July.
It means progress in immunisation coverage has effectively stalled, leaving 2.7 million additional children either unvaccinated or under-vaccinated compared to pre-pandemic levels in 2019.
A marker used to measure immunisation coverage is to look at whether children received three doses of the vaccine against diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis – referred to as DTP3.
Global coverage for DTP3 stalled at 84% in 2023, according to the report.
At the same time, the number of children worldwide, who had not received any vaccinations, had increased.
We refer to these kids as zero-dose children. Ten countries account for 59% of all zero-dose children, with the global number in 2023 rising to 14.5 million, compared to 13.9 million in 2022, according to the report.
Coverage slightly down in SA
Data from the report showed a slight decrease for a number of outcome measures in South Africa between 2022 and 2023. It was one of 14 countries in the African region that saw a decrease in coverage for DTP1 (the first dose of the vaccine for diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis), slipping from 87% in 2022 to 81% in 2023. Coverage for DTP3 also decreased, falling from 85% in 2022 to 79% in 2023.
South Africa was also one of 10 countries in the African region that saw a decrease in coverage for the first dose of the measles vaccine, and was singled out by the report as having the sharpest decline in coverage in the region between 2022 and 2023. Measles coverage dropped from 86% in 2022 to 80% in 2023.
READ | Prof Shabir Madhi: 'Not being afraid to speak out, it does get me into trouble quite often'
Commenting on the accuracy of the new data, Professor Shabir Madhi, the dean at the Faculty of Health Sciences at the University of Witwatersrand (Wits), said it used administrative data, which could bias the estimates.
He explained that the report bases vaccine coverage on the number of vaccines procured by the government and deployed to facilities. For example, if a facility gets 100 doses of the measles vaccine and ends up discarding 50 doses, it doesn't necessarily get reported.
The WHO acknowledges the potential for data inaccuracies. It stated that it calculates the estimated percentage of immunisation coverage by dividing the number of doses administered to a target population by the estimated number of people in that target population.
Madhi said a more accurate picture of childhood immunisation coverage in the country could be found in national vaccine coverage surveys, like the Expanded Programme on Immunisation (EPI) National Coverage survey.
Spotlight previously reported on results from the most recent EPI survey conducted in 2019.
"Not being afraid to speak out, it does get me into trouble quite often," said Madhi.
He said it appeared the new report did not incorporate data from the EPI survey. However, even without this data, he said the WHO estimates were not too far off the local data.
He remarked that he did not feel "too strongly either way" about the accuracy of the WHO data because the bottom line was that vaccine coverage in the country was lagging.
"Fluctuations in immunisation coverage are not uncommon," Dr Haroon Saloojee, a professor of Child Health at Wits University, told Spotlight.
He added:
One should not make too much of a fall or increase in coverage rates over one year, unless it is drastic.
Data from the WHO report for vaccine coverage in South Africa between 2018 and 2022 had actually showed an overall upward trend, which was "promising", according to Saloojee.
However, he said the latest data from the report "holds no good news for South Africa" because the dip in coverage in 2023 was noteworthy.
How does SA compare?
"South Africa's performance is moderate when compared globally, and poor compared to other high middle-income countries," said Saloojee.
"Considering that South Africa is a high middle-income country, we should be performing much better in all our health indicators."
He pointed out that countries in a similar bracket, like Cuba and Uruguay, had achieved high immunisation coverage through robust healthcare systems and effective public health policies.
Regarding zero-dose children, the report ranked South Africa 6th-worst in the African region.
In 2022, the country ranked 13th. With a total of 220 000 zero-dose children, the country accounted for 3% of all zero-dose children in the African region.
Nigeria had the highest percentage, at 32%, of all zero-dosed children in the region, followed by Ethiopia, with 14%.
'Dysfunctionality of primary healthcare'
Apart from the international comparisons, Madhi pointed out that South Africa was not meeting its own targets of having at least 90% of children in each district fully vaccinated.
The EPI survey found that only seven of the 52 districts in the country were able to achieve the national target of 90% of children fully vaccinated under one year of age.
Together, the data from the survey and the WHO clearly showed that childhood immunisation targets were not being met in the country.
READ | SA adopts single dose HPV vaccine regimen, extends govt-subsidised jabs to private schools
For Madhi, the results from the EPI survey "speaks to the dysfunctionality of primary healthcare in the country".
He said the immunisation of children, which is the bedrock of primary healthcare when it comes to children, acts as a "canary in the mine with regards to how well primary healthcare is working".
He said South Africa was a leader in the field in evaluating and introducing vaccines to the public immunisation programme.
But when it comes to implementation, for the vast majority of districts we "are falling completely flat on our face and coming short in terms of reaching our own targets".
Implications for children
The health implications for children, who are not unvaccinated or only partially vaccinated, are significant.
"They are less protected against what can be life-threatening diseases. And those life-threatening diseases include diseases such as measles, but also other life-threatening diseases, such as pneumonia," Madhi said.
"We're selling ourselves short, as a country, in addition to actually compromising the health of children by not ensuring that we're doing everything that's possible to actually get children to be vaccinated."
He added:
It also comes with other consequences, so it sort of lends South Africa to be more prone to outbreaks.
Saloojee added that it was also likely that children who were not fully vaccinated were "not receiving many of the other health, education and social development services all children require and that was being provided by government, such as early childhood development services and child support grants".
The reasons for immunisation coverage lagging are complex and the responsibility for fixing the problem lies with more than just one entity.
Spotlight previously reported on some of the reasons children are remaining unvaccinated or under-immunised as identified by the EPI survey.
READ MORE | What you need to know about the Mpox outbreak in South Africa
Madhi said there needed to be a fundamental relook at the country's immunisation programme.
Proper governance structures needed to be put in place and the programme had to be implemented all the way, down to the sub-districts.
There was also a need for real-time data and monitoring of that data, so interventions could be done when children were missing their immunisations.
He also suggested ring-fencing funds for vaccines, at either a national or provincial level, to ensure that money earmarked for vaccines was used for that purpose to ensure less stock-outs.
"The immunisation programme hasn't changed much from what I can gather over the past 20 years, let alone the past 10 years. So, we can't expect a different outcome if the strategy that we're using, which has failed, is the strategy that you continue pursuing," Madhi said.
Saloojee said the health department could play a pivotal role in strengthening the immunisation programme by "providing leadership, resources and policy support".
He said that, to his knowledge, the health department was currently preparing a national immunisation strategy to take the country to 2030, but the draft was not up to scratch.
The strategy, he says, will need to offer clear objectives, establish realistic indicators of, and targets for, measuring success, and attract a fully funded mandate.
Spotlight asked the department for comment on the new WHO report and how it plans to respond to improve immunisation coverage. While the department acknowledged our questions, it did not provide comment by the time this article was first published.
We live in a world where facts and fiction get blurred
Who we choose to trust can have a profound impact on our lives. Join thousands of devoted South Africans who look to News24 to bring them news they can trust every day. As we celebrate 25 years, become a News24 subscriber as we strive to keep you informed, inspired and empowered.
Next on News24
Inside the not-so-secret 'military' training camp in Mpumalanga, where 95 Libyans learnt skills
1h ago
